Be A Rational Agent

Miscellaneous

Living next to [America] is in some ways like sleeping with an elephant. No matter how friendly and even-tempered is the beast, if I can call it that, one is affected by every twitch and grunt.
-Former Prime Minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau on Canada/US relations

With four major political parties to choose from (not to mention the rising Green party), Canadians are afforded some protection from the strongly polarized politics found down south. However, you can’t live in America’s hat without forming some kind of opinion about what’s happening. After being linked to this extreme-left video and this extreme-right one in the space of a week, my internal BS sensor was overworked and I felt the need to throw in my 2 cents on the issue.

In both of the aforementioned videos, these amateur interviewers head down to the opposite camp’s rally and start doing Michael Moore style interviews (i.e. lots of talking heads and very little substance). In a textbook example of the Straw man fallacy, they single out the dumbest/loudest people in the room and start asking them directed questions about various controversial topics. These people make incredibly ignorant claims and hyperbolic statements (comparing Bush to Hitler? see Godwin’s Law), which the filmmakers love because they can use these to discredit the entire party.

www.overcompensating.com

While these videos are really nothing more than amateur footage on YouTube, they’re symptomatic of a larger social issue; namely, the kind of groupthinking that’s emerging from these political parties. It’s easy and fun to belong to a group. You all believe in the same things, so you can get together and act smug about how you’ve got it all figured out. You can insult the other party’s viewpoint without fear of a counter-argument. If a moral problem is too complicated to think about, you can follow the party line with zeal. By subscribing to the beliefs of a group, you’re immediately undermining yourself as a rational agent. You’re substituting your own reason with the reasoning of the group, and groups are notoriously unreasonable. As Dilbert author Scott Adams put it:

As soon as you tell me “Carl joined a group,” I can tell you Carl is no longer as rational as he used to be. His judgment will start to conform to the group’s judgment, and the group’s judgment will be based on some ever-drifting sense of values that lost its rational connecting tissue long ago.

It’s in this spirit that I invite you to assert yourself as a rational agent by challenging your assumptions. Engage in meaningful dialogue with people who do not share your beliefs, and play Devil’s Advocate sometimes. As author Stephen Covey described it: seek first to understand, then to be understood. If someone is able to argue persuasively against an idea you hold, either research a counter-argument or consider changing your beliefs.

As Chris Rock so eloquently put it (video embedded below, NSFW): in the end you’ll find that you’re liberal about some things and conservative about others, and that’s the way it should be.

Tags:  ·  · 

Minor Update: Feedburner

Miscellaneous

Feedburner LogoI just thought I’d mention that since Blogger has recently improved Feedburner integration, I’ve moved the Quixotic Engineer feed over to there. Why, you ask? Feedburner gives me a bit more control as an author, provides feedback and statistics, and has some other useful features as well.

What does mean for you? Probably not much. If you’re already subscribed to this site’s feed, you may or may not need to re-subscribe to the new Feedburner feed (I’m not sure). If this post has meant nothing to you, never fear, it’s a minor technical matter and you can safely ignore it!

UPDATE: It turns out that redirecting my Atom feed to Feedburner was messing up my Google sitemap, which in turn was causing my pages to be indexed poorly. New subscribers to the feed will now be directed directly to Feedburner, but anyone who subsribed to the old feed will no longer be redirected. This won’t actually affect what you get very much, but I just thought I’d let you know.

→ 1 CommentTags:  ·  · 

The Importance of Pacing

Miscellaneous

I have a friend named Sven in Software Engineering with me at Concordia. While we’ve often collaborated well together on projects, our styles of programming couldn’t be more different.

Sven likes to research and prepare. He reads the class textbook religiously and writes out his algorithms extensively beforehand. When he gets down to the nitty gritty of writing code, he’s already almost done.

Gonzo LogoI, on the other hand, throw myself into programming projects headfirst. I implement new concepts on the fly and learn by doing. I’ve described it as “gonzo coding” to some people, though if I really wanted to be true to Mr. Thompson’s legacy I’d avoid editing too. In practice the opposite is true, with large segments of code needing to be tweaked to fit my mercurial plans and abstract visions.

When planning this blog, however, I took a page from the book of Sven and read lots of advice for new bloggers. Some of it was technical and mostly involved toying with the html of the Blogger template. Some suggestions dealt with the page’s aesthetics, while others referred to accessibility and writing style.

What really struck me was the advice to avoid new blogger burnout. I recognized immediately what they were talking about: I may have a dozen good ideas for new posts right now, but if I update too frequently I may find myself at a loss for fresh ideas in a matter of weeks.

To avoid this predicament, the general consensus was that it is essential to create an update schedule and be consistent. In theory, not only will this set a manageable pace for blogging but also let readers know when they can expect new content.

Therefore, I’m letting you, my handful of readers, know that I plan to publish a new post every Monday, Wednesday and Friday.

Coming this Wednesday: a much more substantial post about webcomics.

→ 3 CommentsTags:

Introduction

Miscellaneous
Blues Brothers

“Blogs are terribly self-serving, aren’t they?” That was the beginning of the first draft of my introduction. That first draft was rambling and cheeky, but it was mostly just cocky. That wasn’t the tone I wanted for this blog, so I figured I’d re-write it and be a little more honest.

Though I’ve adopted the online pseudonym “Mr. Bubbles” for the moment, I may change to my real name eventually. I first have to decide whether or not this blog is too embarrassing for my friends and family to read. I’m a software engineering major studying at Concordia university in Montreal. I could tell you about my interests here, but I think that will mostly be revealed by what I write about, such as music, gaming, books, etc.

To be truthful, I’m still wary that this blog might be entirely narcissistic, so I’ll be writing about things other than myself as much as possible. For the moment, I think I’ll finish with the last paragraph that I salvaged from my first draft: “If you do happen to be a non-me person (of which there are many), feel free to leave a comment. Nasty or nice. I promise that I won’t delete your comments unless I feel like it.”

→ 1 CommentTags:

© 2007-2012 Matthew Gallant, hosted by A Small Orange, powered by Wordpress, theme based on Basic.